William Katz:  Urgent Agenda

HOME      ABOUT     CONTACT 

 

 

 

 

STUNNING REBUKE – QUOTE OF THE DAY – AT 9:52 A.M. ET:  The White House is lining up the usual left-wing suspects to support the Iran agreement.  The same crowd comes out of the woodwork every time Obama snaps his fingers.

But the deal gets a hefty thumbs down from two genuine heavyweights – former Secretaries of State Henry Kissinger and George Shultz, in The Wall Street Journal.   It is hard to refute their logic.  From the Jerusalem Post: 

Two former US secretaries of state - Henry Kissinger and George Shultz - penned an op-ed for The Wall Street Journal on Wednesday criticizing President Barack Obama for the framework agreement his administration reached with Iran last week.

The former top diplomats said that the framework agreement with Iran effectively concedes any option of using military force to compel Iranian compliance.

“Mixing shrewd diplomacy with open defiance of UN resolutions, Iran has gradually turned the negotiation on its head,” Kissinger and Shultz wrote in the Journal. “Iran’s centrifuges have multiplied from about 100 at the beginning of the negotiation to almost 20,000 today. The threat of war now constrains the West more than Iran.”

“While Iran treated the mere fact of its willingness to negotiate as a concession, the West has felt compelled to break every deadlock with a new proposal. In the process, the Iranian program has reached a point officially described as being within two to three months of building a nuclear weapon. Under the proposed agreement, for 10 years Iran will never be further than one year from a nuclear weapon and, after a decade, will be significantly closer.”

And...

"In a large country with multiple facilities and ample experience in nuclear concealment, violations will be inherently difficult to detect," they wrote. "Devising theoretical models of inspection is one thing. Enforcing compliance, week after week, despite competing international crises and domestic distractions, is another."

"Any report of a violation is likely to prompt debate over its significance - or even calls for new talks with Tehran to explore the issue. The experience of Iran’s work on a heavy-water reactor during the 'interim agreement' period - when suspect activity was identified but played down in the interest of a positive negotiating atmosphere - is not encouraging."

COMMENT:  Kissinger and Shultz are, of course, correct.   They understand the psychology of diplomacy, not just its talking points.  Yes, if Iran violates the agreement, what will we actually do?  What will Germany do, with business with Iran booming?  What will the UN do?  What will the next president do?  What if there's another crisis, perhaps in Asia?  Will we even pay attention?

The Iranians, known for their negotiating skill, have gotten the best of Obama, known as one of the worst negotiators ever to sit in the White House.

April 8,  2015